Good job. Well done. I’m so proud of you. I think praise is one of the most habitual phrases in modern parenting, offered so constantly and so automatically that most parents have never once stopped to ask what it is actually doing, or what a child is quietly learning underneath the warmth of it.
It is far quicker to say amazing than to actually look.
What Constant Praise Actually Trains
Praise, delivered generically and often, teaches a child to watch for the reaction rather than to develop their own internal sense of what they have actually done. A child drawing a picture, told “amazing” before they have even finished, begins to learn that the point of drawing is the response it produces, not the drawing itself. I think this is a genuinely significant shift, redirecting a child’s attention outward, toward approval, at exactly the age they are meant to be building an inward sense of their own competence and interest.
Why Praise Feels Like Good Parenting
I understand why praise gets reached for so constantly. It feels encouraging, warm, the opposite of criticism, and it is offered with real love almost every time. I think the warmth is genuine and the effect is still, very often, the opposite of what is intended, because praise this frequent stops functioning as information and starts functioning as a kind of ambient noise a child learns to tune out or, worse, to become quietly dependent on.
The Mirror That Reflects Nothing Specific
A mirror that shows only a vague, generic outline, rather than the actual person standing in front of it, is not really reflecting anyone at all. A child offered constant, generic praise is looking into exactly that kind of mirror, hoping to see themselves accurately shown back, and finding instead a shape so general it could belong to any child, doing any thing, on any day.
“Amazing” and “well done,” repeated often enough, stop reflecting the specific child and the specific thing they actually did. They become a mirror with nothing particular in it at all.
A Different Lens
Your child finishes a puzzle and looks up at you immediately, and you say, without really looking, that’s amazing, well done.
The thought that runs through most parents’ minds in that moment is immediate. I should encourage this, positive reinforcement builds confidence. What follows is a quick, generic response, delivered while doing something else, and the child, having registered the tone more than the words, goes looking for the next thing to be praised for rather than settling into what they just did.
Every child arrives already expecting to be genuinely watched, not managed from a distance, and generic praise, however frequent, does not meet that expectation. It substitutes a quick verdict for actual attention, and a child’s body tends to know the difference, even if they could never explain it.
They weren’t fishing for approval because they’re needy. They were checking whether you had actually noticed, because a quick well done, offered without real attention behind it, rarely convinces anyone that they were truly seen.
The Trap This Sets for Well Meaning Parents
Praise feels like an easy, low cost way to be a supportive parent, and I think that ease is exactly the trap. It is far quicker to say “amazing” than to actually look, and a parent doing the quick version can genuinely believe they are building their child’s confidence, while the child is quietly learning that the response matters more than the work.
What Tends to Help Instead
I am not arguing against ever praising a child, and I am not suggesting warmth be withheld. I am arguing for specificity and genuine attention over volume. Naming what actually happened, you kept trying even when that piece didn’t fit, rather than a generic verdict, tends to build real internal confidence in a way constant, generic praise never quite manages.
A Different Way of Reading Behaviour
Praise, offered constantly and without real attention behind it, trains a child to look outward for a verdict rather than inward for their own sense of what they have done. Once you start noticing how often praise substitutes for actually looking, I think it becomes very hard to reach for the automatic well done quite so easily again.
See what your child is actually checking for.
I’ve built a free AI Agent that lets you explore what this might mean for your own child, in your own home, right now, drawing directly on nearly forty years of research, raising my own two daughters, and hands-on experience with the families I have worked with since. No pressure, no commitment.
Try the Free Agent